Refund policy
Last updated: November 18, 2026
Free returns and exchanges within 30 days
If a piece isn't right, send it back within 30 days of delivery for a full refund of the piece or an exchange for another one. Return shipping is free: we email you a prepaid label.
- Holiday gifts: pieces bought between November 15 and December 24, 2026 can be returned or exchanged until January 31, 2027.
- Got it as a gift? You can exchange it or get a New Heritage gift card for its value. We won't tell the person who bought it.
How it works
- Email attention@newheritage.shop or message us on WhatsApp with your order number.
- We send you a prepaid return label within 1 business day.
- Pack the piece unworn, in its original box, and drop it off with the carrier.
- When it arrives, we refund your original payment method within 5 business days, or ship your new piece at no cost.
Pieces must come back unworn and undamaged. For hygiene, earrings must never have been worn. If a piece arrives worn or damaged by use, we can't refund it and we'll ship it back to you. If you exchange for a piece that costs more, you pay the difference; if it costs less, we refund the difference. Original shipping charges are not refunded.
Arrived damaged or with a defect?
Email attention@newheritage.shop within 30 days of delivery with your order number and a photo of the piece. We replace it, or refund it in full if we can't. If we need it back, the return is free.
Our .925 sterling silver guarantee
Every piece we sell as sterling silver is .925 sterling silver. If a piece we sold as sterling silver turns out not to be .925 sterling silver, we refund it in full, including what you paid for shipping. Email attention@newheritage.shop with your order number and the result of a test done by a jeweler, and we'll tell you how to send the piece back at no cost to you.
Gift cards
New Heritage gift cards never expire. They can be used on any piece in our online store and can't be used to buy another gift card. Gift cards are not refundable and can't be exchanged for cash, except where the law requires it. Pieces bought with a gift card follow this same policy; any approved refund goes back to the gift card.
Refunds
Refunds go back to your original payment method within 5 business days after we receive the piece. Your bank or card issuer may take a little longer to post it. If you paid with Shop Pay installments, the refund is applied to your installment plan.
Questions about an order, a return or a claim? Email attention@newheritage.shop.
New Heritage Jewelry LLC · 8206 Louisiana Blvd NE, Ste A #10197, Albuquerque, NM 87113